His remarks came just hours after the nation marked Jamhuri Day celebrations at Nyayo Stadium on December 12, 2025.
In a statement shared on X, Mutua challenged the common perception that public participation genuinely empowers citizens, arguing instead that it is often used to advance the interests of political elites rather than the public.
In a statement shared on X, Mutua challenged the common perception that public participation genuinely empowers citizens, arguing instead that it is often used to advance the interests of political elites rather than the public.
He suggested that the process, as currently practiced, serves as a tool to legitimize decisions that have already been made by those in power, leaving ordinary citizens with little real influence.
“In a democracy, public participation is a charade often used by courts to strike out government policies they don’t like, or oppose a President they loathe,” Mutua said.
“In a democracy, public participation is a charade often used by courts to strike out government policies they don’t like, or oppose a President they loathe,” Mutua said.
“In reality, public participation is one more fraud of John Locke. It’s a fiction of democracy.”
Mutua’s critique goes beyond theory, highlighting practical shortcomings in how public consultation is implemented.
Mutua’s critique goes beyond theory, highlighting practical shortcomings in how public consultation is implemented.
He noted that while the process can create the appearance of citizen involvement, it rarely translates into measurable improvements in governance or policy outcomes.
“That’s because public participation is so theoretically and empirically vacuous that it doesn’t tell you whether a particular policy is objectively good for a country,” he said.
“That’s because public participation is so theoretically and empirically vacuous that it doesn’t tell you whether a particular policy is objectively good for a country,” he said.
“It only serves as a fig leaf for legitimacy by elites to justify what they want to do.”
While acknowledging that public engagement has some potential benefits, Mutua warned that these are often limited and symbolic.
While acknowledging that public engagement has some potential benefits, Mutua warned that these are often limited and symbolic.
He argued that participation may educate segments of the population but falls short of offering a scientific or definitive measure of democratic legitimacy.
Mutua’s comments coincided with a legal development regarding the controversial US-Kenya health deal.
Mutua’s comments coincided with a legal development regarding the controversial US-Kenya health deal.
On December 10, 2025, the High Court issued conservatory orders suspending the multi-billion-shilling health agreement signed between Kenya and the United States.
The court’s decision prevents the implementation of the health framework until a full hearing is concluded.
The development has sparked public debate about the transparency and accountability of major government agreements.
The development has sparked public debate about the transparency and accountability of major government agreements.
Mutua suggested that the debate over the health deal illustrates the limits of public participation in ensuring that citizens’ interests are adequately protected.
“The notion that citizens can meaningfully influence decisions of this magnitude is, in practice, more illusion than reality,” he said.
“The notion that citizens can meaningfully influence decisions of this magnitude is, in practice, more illusion than reality,” he said.
Social Plugin